Non-Shielded Arc Welding: Pros, Cons, and Applications | Big Easy Mobile Welders
welding on site

Exploring Non-Shielded Arc Welding Pros Cons Applications

In the world of welding, non-shielded arc welding has become a topic of great interest among professionals and enthusiasts alike. When considering non-shielded arc welding, one must weigh the pros and cons of its applications in order to make an informed decision.

This blog post will provide an in-depth analysis on non-shielded arc welding by first defining the term and discussing industries where it is commonly used. We will then explore its various benefits such as mobility advantage in industrial settings, cost-effectiveness compared to other methods like FCAW or GMAW, versatility with metals and alloys, as well as environmental benefits including reduced pollution and corrosion resistance.

Furthermore, we’ll address some of the drawbacks associated with non-shielded arc welding which include unsuitability for thin substrates, irreplaceable electrodes requiring caution during use, and lower deposition rates affecting project timelines.

Lastly, alternative welding methods such as laser welding, plasma welding and electron beam welding will be discussed to offer additional options for those seeking optimal solutions tailored specifically to their needs.

Table of Contents:

Non-Shielded Arc Welding Overview

Non-shielded arc welding, also known as Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW), is a popular and cost-effective method of joining metal and steel using electricity. The process generates extreme heat, which can reach up to 6,500 degrees Fahrenheit. SMAW has been widely used for decades in various industries such as wear and tear repair, construction processes, and manufacturing due to its numerous advantages.

This versatile welding process involves the use of an electric arc that forms between a consumable electrode covered with flux and the workpiece. The intense heat produced by the arc melts both the base material and the electrode’s tip, creating a molten pool that solidifies into a high-quality weld once cooled down.

There are several types of non-shielded arc welding techniques available today including gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW), flux-cored arc welding (FCAW), gas metal arc welding (GMAW), submerged arc welding (SAW) and more.

Each technique offers unique benefits depending on specific applications or requirements.

welder using stick welding

  • Mobility: Non-shielded arc welders are easy to transport from one place to another, making them ideal for industrial settings where mobility is essential.
  • Cost-effectiveness: Compared to other welding methods like FCAW or GMAW, SMAW is less expensive since there’s no gas involved in the process; thus fewer pieces of equipment are needed.

Non-shielded arc welding is a versatile welding process that can be used in various industries. It is a cost-effective method that produces high-quality welds. With its mobility and cost-effectiveness, non-shielded arc welding is an excellent choice for many welding applications.

Non-Shielded Arc Welding is a reliable and cost-effective welding process for many industrial applications. Its mobility advantage makes it an attractive choice in certain settings. However, there are some drawbacks to consider before committing to this method of welding which will be discussed in the next heading: Pros of Non-Shielded Arc Welding.

Pros of Non-Shielded Arc Welding

One of the primary benefits of non-shielded arc welding is its mobility. The portability of the materials used in this technique makes it suitable for industrial and manufacturing contexts where mobility is necessary. Additionally, compared to other welding methods like Flux-cored Arc Welding (FCAW) or Gas Metal Arc Welding (GMAW), Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW) is less expensive since there’s no gas involved in the process; thus fewer pieces of equipment are needed.

Mobility Advantage in Industrial Settings

The portability aspect makes non-shielded arc welding a popular choice among businesses that require on-site repairs or installations. Companies like Big Easy Mobile Welders, which offer mobile welding services in New Orleans, can quickly move their equipment and personnel between job sites without any hassle.

Cost-Effectiveness Compared to FCAW or GMAW

  • No Need for Shielding Gases: Unlike FCAW and GMAW processes that use costly shielding gases such as argon or carbon dioxide, Shielded Metal Arc Welding relies solely on electricity and consumable electrodes covered with flux material.
  • Fewer Tools Required: With a simple electric power source, electrode holder (stinger), and a welding helmet, non-shielded arc welding can be performed without the need for additional tools or equipment.
  • Lower Initial Investment: The cost of setting up a non-shielded arc welding station is generally lower than that of other methods like FCAW or GMAW, making it an attractive option for small businesses and homeowners looking to invest in their own welding setup.

Non-Shielded Arc Welding offers numerous advantages, including mobility and cost-effectiveness in industrial settings. Furthermore, its versatility with metals and alloys makes it a great choice for many welding projects.

Wide Range Compatibility with Metals

SMAW, also known as non-shielded arc welding, is a versatile technique that can be used to join an array of materials including carbon steel, stainless steel, cast iron, nickel-based alloys and even some non-ferrous metals such as aluminum. The process’s adaptability ensures that it remains an essential part of many welding processes, from construction sites to manufacturing plants.

Reduced Need for Specialized Equipment

  • Mobility: Non-shielded arc welding requires minimal setup time compared to other methods like gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) or submerged arc welding (SAW). Its portable nature enables welders to move quickly between job sites while maintaining high-quality welds.
  • Economical: Since the process doesn’t require shielding gases or consumable electrode-covered fluxes found in FCAW/GMAW systems, companies save money by avoiding these additional expenses when using SMAW instead.
  • Simplicity: The straightforward operation involved in stick welding makes it easier for workers who are new to the trade or those looking to expand their skill set.

The versatility of non-shielded arc welding with metals and alloys makes it a great choice for many applications. With its environmental benefits, this type of welding is becoming increasingly popular in the industry.

Environmental Benefits

One of the often-overlooked advantages of non-shielded arc welding, or Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW), is its environmental friendliness. This type of welding process has a significantly lower impact on the environment compared to other methods such as Flux-cored Arc Welding (FCAW) or Gas Metal Arc Welding (GMAW). The following are some reasons why SMAW is considered more eco-friendly:

  • Lower emissions: Non-shielded arc welding produces less smoke and sparks during operation, which can help reduce air pollution in industrial settings.
  • No shielding gas required: Unlike FCAW and GMAW processes that use shielding gases like carbon dioxide or argon, SMAWs do not require any additional gases for protection. This reduces both costs and potential greenhouse gas emissions associated with these gases.
  • Corrosion resistance: Another advantage of using shielded metal arc welding techniques is their ability to provide corrosion resistance for metals prone to rust over time. This means that structures created using this method will have a longer lifespan, reducing waste generated from repairs or replacements.

In addition to these benefits, choosing an experienced mobile welding service provider like Big Easy Mobile Welders can further contribute to a greener welding process by reducing transportation emissions and energy consumption. By bringing the necessary equipment directly to your location, we help minimize our environmental footprint while still providing high-quality welds for your projects.

Non-shielded arc welding is a great option for those looking to reduce emissions and protect against rust. Yet, prior to deciding on this welding technique, it is essential to take into account some potential drawbacks.

Cons of Non-Shielded Arc Welding

Despite the benefits associated with shielded metal arc welding processes like SMAW, there are some disadvantages worth considering before opting for this technique. Some limitations include unsuitability for thinner materials, irreplaceable welding electrodes, and a low deposition rate which can result in slower overall project completion times.

Not Suitable for Thin Materials

Non-shielded arc welding is not recommended when dealing with thin materials, as the intense heat produced during the process can lead to warping or burning. GTAW or GMAW could be a better fit for thinner materials than non-shielded arc welding, as the higher temperature generated during the process can cause warping or burning.

Irreplaceable Welding Electrodes

In non-shielded arc welding, the consumable electrode covered in flux is used up during the process and must be replaced frequently. This leads to increased downtime and higher costs compared to other welding processes, such as GMAW or GTAW that use non-consumable tungsten electrodes.

Low Deposition Rate Compared to Other Methods

  • MIG Welding: Gas Metal Arc Welding (GMAW), also known as MIG (Metal Inert Gas) welding, offers a faster deposition rate than SMAW because it uses a continuous wire feed instead of individual rods.
  • Submerged Arc Welding: Another alternative, submerged arc welding (SAW), also provides a higher deposition rate due to its continuous wire feed and shielding gas.

Non-shielded arc welding has its drawbacks, such as not being suitable for thin materials and irreplaceable electrodes. However, there are alternative welding processes that may be more efficient and user-friendly.

Alternative Welding Processes

There are several alternative types of welding processes available depending on specific needs. These methods offer unique advantages and can be more suitable for certain applications compared to non-shielded arc welding. Some popular alternatives include:

Shielded Metal Arc Welding- Big Easy Mobile Welders

  • Laser Welding: This technique uses high-powered lasers to join metals, providing precise control and minimal heat distortion.
  • Plasma Welding: By using high-velocity jets of plasma, this method offers faster travel speeds and increased penetration depth.
  • Electron Beam Welding: Utilizing beams of high-velocity electrons, this process is ideal for joining dissimilar materials or creating vacuum-tight seals.
  • Friction Welding: Employed in various industries such as automotive and aerospace, friction welding uses heat generated by mechanical pressure to create strong joints between metal surfaces.

For beginners looking into learning about different forms of metal joining procedures, Oxy-Acetylene Gas Welding is considered one of the most beginner-friendly options due to its simplicity and low cost. On the other hand, if speed is a priority, MIG (Metal Inert Gas) Welding is one of the fastest processes available today, offering high-quality welds and increased productivity. Learn more about MIG welding here.


Non-shielded arc welding offers many advantages such as mobility in industrial settings, lower emissions and rust prevention; however, its drawbacks include an inability to weld thin materials, reliance on electrodes that are not reusable and a slower deposition rate than other methods.

It offers mobility advantages in industrial settings, lower emissions compared to other methods, and corrosion resistance for rust-prone metals. However, it may not be suitable for thin materials, requires irreplaceable welding electrodes, and has a lower deposition rate than other methods.

If you’re looking for reliable mobile welding services that utilize various welding techniques including non-shielded arc welding, look no further than Big Easy Mobile Welding. Our team of experienced welders can handle any project with precision and efficiency. Contact us today to get started!

Free Estimates